[04] Recent enforcement decisions

Publicly reported judgments, across the region.

CONTEXT · The decisions below are publicly reported court judgments involving software publishers as plaintiffs. They are presented as illustration of the enforcement landscape across the region — not as a record of matters on which the firm was counsel of record.

SPC IP TRIBUNAL · CHINA · 2020

Siemens Industry Software v. Guangzhou Wofu Mold

Engineering-software publisher Siemens succeeded against a Chinese mould manufacturer for unlicensed installation of NX. On appeal, the Supreme People's Court raised damages substantially after the defendant obstructed the trial court's evidence-preservation order — applying an adverse inference from the unpreserved computers.

CNY 2.7M
DAMAGES ON APPEAL RAISED FROM CNY 600K
HIGH COURT · MALAYSIA · 2024

Siemens v. Unicorn

Software publisher Siemens recovered damages against a Malaysian engineering company found to have used unlicensed Siemens NX. The Court calibrated the award by reference to actual licence pricing, awarding approximately a fifth of the publisher's claim — useful guidance on how Malaysian courts approach quantum in software-copyright matters.

RM 1.05M
DAMAGES AWARDED ≈ USD 224,000
PEOPLE'S COURT · VIETNAM · 2022

Software-publisher civil claim, Binh Duong

A 2022 People's Court decision awarding material damages of 4.6 billion VND for software piracy — a figure roughly sixty-five times the maximum administrative sanction available for the same conduct. Cited as a marker of Vietnam's shift toward meaningful civil remedies for software publishers.

VND 4.6B
DAMAGES AWARDED ≈ USD 185,000

→ Sources: Lexology / Rouse · contemporaneous reporting · Supreme People's Court (PRC) · Malaysian High Court · People's Court of Binh Duong